top of page

Why We Can Start Hating People on the Other Side

Nov 4
5 min read
Cream and green variegation with deep cutouts along the edges.
A Devil monstera with pale, lacy leaves and fine green veining, in a white pot.


Contempt is a response that doesn't feel like it arrives as a decision. It tends to build in stages, and each stage can feel reasonable from inside. A disagreement becomes a frustration, frustration becomes suspicion, and eventually the person on the other side begins to represent something larger than themselves. What was once a difference between two people becomes a division between two kinds of people.


It can begin with threat. When political outcomes carry weight for safety, belonging, moral convictions, and the future, people who support an opposing position may begin to register as part of the danger. Anger can become a way of responding to that perceived threat, bringing a sense of energy and direction to something that otherwise feels overwhelming. A body that reacts when the situation is safe may remain alert long after the immediate disagreement has ended, especially when reminders of the conflict continue to arrive.


Group identity adds another layer. Shared beliefs can create belonging, and a perceived common threat can strengthen the boundaries between those inside and outside the group. Agreement offers reassurance that others see the danger too, while expressions of anger may receive approval, encouragement, or attention. Over time, the group can become a place where hostility feels less like hostility and more like loyalty. Questioning the intensity may begin to feel like questioning the people one belongs to.


Flattening follows. A group of millions becomes one person with one motive. The loudest and worst examples often attract the most attention, and repeated exposure can make those examples appear representative of everyone. A face that once had a history shrinks to a type, and a type requires little curiosity. The mind fills the gaps with assumed intentions, interpreting the other side's actions through suspicion while extending its own side the benefit of the doubt. The myth of the monster touches something close, the way a person becomes easier to hate once reduced to a single frightening shape.


Moral certainty can make this division harder to recognize. When someone believes an issue concerns fundamental questions of right and wrong, disagreement may no longer seem like a different judgment about a complicated problem. It can begin to look like evidence of another person's character. Their position becomes proof of selfishness, ignorance, cruelty, or indifference, even when little is known about how they arrived there. The possibility that another person may hold a conviction for reasons that differ from those assigned to them becomes increasingly difficult to consider.


Hatred can also offer something psychologically compelling. It converts helplessness into direction. A threat too large and too distant to influence directly acquires a recognizable target, and that target gives the anger somewhere to go. Certainty comes with it, and certainty can feel like clarity after a long stretch of dread. There may even be moments of relief in identifying someone to blame, particularly when uncertainty has become difficult to tolerate. Protective states are not the problem, but the strategies that develop around them can begin to create difficulties of their own. Contempt may feel protective while gradually narrowing the person's ability to see anyone outside the group clearly.


Strong disagreement can rest on real stakes, and real wrongs exist. Understanding the psychological processes that contribute to hatred does not make every position equally reasonable or every action equally defensible. People can recognize harm, oppose destructive behavior, and maintain firm moral boundaries without reducing everyone associated with an opposing position to the same character or intention.


The costs gather quietly by how sleep suffers, attention narrows, and the body may remain prepared for arguments that have not happened. Relationships take the hit, the cousin muted, the friend dropped, the table where conversation has turned careful. Shutting down during conflict can become another response, where emotional exhaustion or overwhelm leads someone to withdraw rather than continue engaging. Even familiar relationships can begin to feel like places where a disagreement is waiting to happen.


Some people notice a change in themselves before they recognize the pattern. Humor develops a harder edge, conversations begin with references to "those people," and another person's misfortune brings a moment of satisfaction that feels uncomfortable afterward. The person may still understand themselves as compassionate and fair, while making increasingly broad exceptions for those they have come to distrust. Hostility becomes easier to justify when it is experienced as a response to someone else's perceived wrongdoing.


Seen this way, hatred toward the other side can develop through a combination of perceived threat, belonging, moral judgment, and repeated reinforcement. It does not necessarily begin with a desire to harm anyone, and understanding how it develops does not excuse what someone chooses to do with it. The feeling may have an understandable history while still carrying consequences for the person experiencing it and those around them.


Work with this pattern can involve examining the fear, helplessness, and personal meaning beneath the contempt, along with the assumptions that have become difficult to question. The aim is not to remove convictions, excuse genuine wrongdoing, or insist that every relationship be preserved. It is to create enough room for someone to distinguish a person's actions and beliefs from the larger category they have come to represent. A disagreement may remain serious, a boundary may still be necessary, and a relationship may not return to what it was. But the other person no longer has to become an entire group in the mind.






This article is intended for general informational purposes and isn’t a substitute for individualized clinical assessment. If political conflict has begun to affect sleep, mood, or relationships, a licensed therapist can help identify what’s happening and what will help.







Nathanael “Nando” Schlecht, LAC, is a trauma therapist in Tucson, AZ, specializing in complex trauma, nervous system regulation, EMDR, and Brainspotting/DBR/Ego State work. He works with high-functioning adults whose alertness has outlasted the conditions that built it, offering telehealth across Arizona including Phoenix, Scottsdale, Flagstaff, and Sedona. Learn more at nandotherapy.com, or to inquire about working together, visit /therapy-contact.





Related Reading:


Why Politics Can Feel Personally Threatening

How political disagreement can activate concerns about safety, belonging, identity, and moral conviction, making opposing views feel more personally threatening than distant.


The Myth of the Monster

How reducing a person to a single frightening category makes contempt easier by replacing complexity with a simpler story about who they are.


Why Does My Body React When I Know I’m Safe?How threat responses can remain active even when the immediate conflict has passed, especially when reminders continue to reinforce a sense of danger.

Comments


bottom of page