top of page

The Psychology of “How Could Anyone Believe That?”

10 minutes ago
6 min read
A twisted olive trunk rising from a grassy clearing, with limestone behind it.
An ancient olive tree with a gnarled trunk and a crown of silver-green leaves.


People tend to naturally experience much of their understanding of the world as straightforward perception. What seems true can feel like the way things are, rather than one interpretation among several. When a belief has become particularly certain, it may no longer seem to require much explanation. Someone who disagrees then presents a dilemma. If the answer appears obvious, the other person must be missing information, reasoning poorly, or acting in bad faith.


These explanations can protect the assumption that one's own perspective is simply an accurate reading of reality. Psychologists use the term naive realism to describe the tendency to experience one's subjective perceptions as objective and to interpret disagreement accordingly. The tendency is not confined to any political position.


Yet people typically don't have complete access to how their own beliefs developed. Some convictions emerge through intentional contemplation, while others take shape through trusted relationships, repeated exposure, personal experiences, and assumptions that aren't challenged. A person may remember when they became convinced of something without recognizing all the influences that made the conclusion seem reasonable in the first place.


Those influences can be difficult to see from within. A trusted parent, teacher, community, or source of information may have shaped the questions someone learned to ask, the evidence they considered important, and the explanations they found believable. Over time, the resulting beliefs can feel entirely self-evident. Another person's position arrives without that history attached, making it easier to see the conclusion as irrational rather than as the result of a different path.


Information mediums and sources can widen the misunderstandings. Two people may follow the same events for years while encountering different accounts of what happened, which details matter, and what those details mean. Each may develop an internally coherent understanding that leaves out information emphasized by the other. Even when both encounter the same evidence, they may interpret its significance differently because of prior expectations, personal experiences, or the credibility they assign to particular sources.


The difficulty increases when the opposing position is encountered primarily through its most provocative speakers. A person may repeatedly hear the least thoughtful arguments from another group while becoming familiar with the strongest explanations offered by their own. Eventually, the comparison feels obvious. One side appears careful and reasonable, while the other seems incapable of recognizing what should be plain to anyone. The myth of the monster describes a related process, where a person becomes easier to dismiss or fear once their complexity has been replaced by a simplified image.


Values also influence what people consider reasonable. Fairness, loyalty, safety, freedom, responsibility, and tradition can matter deeply to people who nevertheless give them different priorities when those values come into conflict. Two individuals may agree that a problem deserves attention while disagreeing about its causes, which consequences matter most, or what a proposed solution would actually accomplish. One may see a particular decision as necessary protection, while another understands it as an unacceptable restriction. The disagreement is not always located in the facts alone.


This does not mean every conclusion is equally supported. Evidence can be incomplete, misunderstood, selectively presented, or rejected for reasons that have little to do with its quality. People can make genuine errors in reasoning, and some beliefs persist despite strong evidence against them. Understanding why someone holds a position helps explain the belief's development, but it does not establish whether the belief is accurate.


There is another aspect to the question, one that concerns what happens when certainty itself begins to feel protective. Imagining how an intelligent, thoughtful person could arrive at an opposing conclusion may introduce uncomfortable possibilities. Perhaps the issue is more complicated than it first appeared. Perhaps some evidence has been overlooked, or a trusted explanation deserves closer examination. The possibility of reconsidering a belief does not necessarily threaten a person's identity, but it can when that belief has become closely connected to belonging, morality, or a sense of security. Under those conditions, dismissing the opposing position may feel easier than allowing the uncertainty to develop.


Exasperation can serve a protective function. Protective states are not the problem, although the responses that develop around them can create difficulties of their own. When a disagreement feels threatening, certainty may help someone regain a sense of steadiness. The question “How could anyone believe that?” can then become a way to end the discomfort without examining what produced it. The person does not necessarily recognize the response as defensive. From inside, it may simply feel like common sense.


Social belonging can reinforce the reaction. In a group where certain views are widely shared, disbelief at an opposing position may receive laughter, agreement, or approval. The expression communicates more than disagreement. It demonstrates familiarity with the group's expectations and reassures others about where the speaker stands. Over time, the question may become part of the language of belonging, repeated often enough that its original meaning receives little attention.


A conversation can close before it has really begun. Someone expresses a belief, another person responds with disbelief, and the first person recognizes that an explanation is unlikely to be received with much interest. They may become defensive, withdraw, or answer with equal contempt. Both leave with their original impressions strengthened. Each sees the other's reaction as further evidence that meaningful discussion is impossible.


Sometimes the disagreement reveals a genuine incompatibility, and continued discussion is neither necessary nor productive. There are also situations where hostility, repeated dishonesty, or disregard for another person's safety makes distance appropriate. Curiosity does not require endless engagement, and understanding another person's reasoning does not create an obligation to maintain a relationship.


The same words, however, can carry very different intentions. Asked with genuine interest, “How could anyone believe that?” becomes a question about the experiences, information, assumptions, and values that led someone toward a conclusion. Asked with contempt, it becomes a statement that no reasonable explanation could exist. The difference may be heard in the tone, but it becomes especially apparent in what follows. One person makes room for an answer, while another has already decided what the answer must reveal.


This distinction is important to notice because understanding is not the same as agreement. Someone can become more familiar with the reasoning behind a position and remain firmly opposed to it. In fact, a more accurate understanding may make it possible to disagree with greater precision, responding to what the other person actually believes rather than to an assumed motive or an exaggerated version of their argument. The conviction does not have to weaken for the explanation to become more complete.


Work with this area of response can involve noticing what happens when an opposing belief is encountered and what the immediate reaction seems to protect. For some, the discomfort may involve uncertainty or the possibility of having been mistaken. For others, it may touch older experiences of conflict, rejection, or being surrounded by people whose judgments felt threatening. The aim is not to persuade someone to accept beliefs they consider wrong or harmful. It is to create enough room between the reaction and the conclusion that the person can recognize what they know, what they assume, and what remains uncertain.


Early changes may be difficult to notice. Someone hears an opposing position and recognizes the familiar surge of disbelief without immediately turning it into a judgment about the person expressing it. A conversation may still end in disagreement, but the disagreement remains attached to a particular claim rather than expanding into a verdict about someone's entire character. Occasionally, curiosity appears where contempt would have arrived before.






This article is intended for general informational purposes and isn’t a substitute for individualized clinical assessment. If political conflict has begun to affect sleep, mood, or close relationships, a licensed therapist can help identify what’s happening and what will help.






Nathanael “Nando” Schlecht, LAC, is a trauma therapist in Tucson, AZ, specializing in complex trauma, nervous system regulation, EMDR, and Brainspotting/DBR/Ego State work. He works with high-functioning adults whose alertness has outlasted the conditions that built it, offering telehealth across Arizona including Phoenix, Scottsdale, Flagstaff, and Sedona. Learn more at nandotherapy.com, or to inquire about working together, visit /therapy-contact.







Related Reading:


Why We Can Start Hating People on the Other Side

How perceived threat, group identity, moral certainty, and simplified assumptions about the opposing side can gradually turn disagreement into contempt.


Why Politics Can Feel Personally Threatening

How political beliefs can become tied to safety, belonging, morality, and identity, making challenges to those beliefs feel more consequential than an ordinary difference of opinion.


When Political Disagreement Starts Feeling Like Moral Betrayal

How political differences can shift from disagreements about ideas into judgments about another person’s values, character, loyalty, or concern for others.

Comments


bottom of page